The Truth About Cat Treats – 5 Common Mistakes Owners Make (and How to Avoid Them)
Treating Your Cat the Right Way
March 2025
Cat owners love to spoil their feline companions, but too much of a good thing can have unintended consequences. Dr Claire Jenkins, founder and CEO of VetChat and Breeder Celect Ambassador, shares expert insights into the common mistakes cat owners make when giving treats and how to ensure their pets stay healthy and happy.
"Treats can be a great way to bond with your cat, but knowing how to use them wisely is essential for their well-being," says Dr Claire Jenkins. When given in moderation and with the right ingredients, treats can be a positive addition to your cat’s diet. However, many owners make mistakes that can negatively impact their pet’s health. Choosing a high-quality treat ensures your cat gets the best nutrition while enjoying a delicious reward.
1. Overfeeding Treats
It’s easy to give in to those pleading eyes, but too many treats can lead to weight gain and serious health concerns. “One of the biggest mistakes is overfeeding treats, which can contribute to obesity and related health issues,” says Dr Jenkins. “Consuming more calories than a cat expends results in excess energy being stored as fat. Over time, this can lead to obesity, diabetes and joint problems.” Additionally, over-reliance on treats may lead to nutritional imbalances and picky eating. “Some cats may start refusing their regular diet in favour of treats, which disrupts their overall nutrition,” she warns. To prevent this, opt for portion-controlled, nutritious treats, designed to support a balanced diet.
2. Choosing Treats with Poor Nutritional Value
Not all treats are created equal. Some contain high levels of salt, sugar, artificial colours and preservatives, which can be harmful. “Some treats may taste good to cats, but they don’t necessarily provide any nutritional benefits,” warns Dr Jenkins. “Avoid treats with excessive salt, sugar, artificial colours or preservatives.” Instead, she advises, “Prioritise high-protein, low-calorie treats made with natural ingredients.” Treat options, which are formulated with high-quality, natural ingredients, make them an excellent choice for owners looking to provide a healthy reward for their cats.
3. Using Treats as Meal Replacements
Treats should never be a substitute for a well-balanced diet. “Treats should complement a cat’s diet, not replace their regular meals,” advises Dr Jenkins. “Cats need essential nutrients from their primary diet to maintain optimal health, and relying too much on treats can lead to deficiencies.” To avoid this, Dr Jenkins recommends treating in moderation and ensuring that no more than 10% of a cat’s daily energy intake comes from treats. “Giving treats once or twice daily in small amounts is appropriate. Always follow the feeding guidelines on the packaging.”
4. Ignoring Specific Dietary Needs
Every cat has unique dietary requirements; some may have allergies or sensitivities to certain ingredients. “Cats have unique nutritional requirements, and some treats may not be suitable for all,” explains Dr Jenkins. “Owners should always check ingredients and consult their vet if they are unsure about what treats are best for their pet.” For those looking for healthier alternatives, Dr Jenkins suggests natural options such as cooked, unseasoned chicken or fish, freeze-dried meat treats and small portions of cat-safe vegetables like steamed carrots or pumpkin.
5. Inconsistent Treat-Giving Practices
Randomly giving treats without consistency can confuse your cat and lead to undesirable behaviours. “Inconsistent treat-giving can confuse cats and lead to behavioural issues,” says Dr Jenkins. “Cats thrive on routine, so it’s best to have a structured approach to treating, such as using them as positive reinforcement for good behaviour.” Treats can be a great training tool, offering a consistent and healthy way to reinforce positive behaviour.
By making informed decisions, cat owners can show their love while keeping their pets healthy and thriving. Moderation, high-quality ingredients, and a structured approach to treating can ensure your cat gets the best of both worlds.
Note: This blog is for informational purposes only. Please consult with a veterinarian for personalised advice regarding your pet’s health.